Well Played Club CASE 01 · FILE 03/09 SUPPORT bg en
CASE 01 The Loophole
SEARCH
CASE 01 · FILE 03/09 VERIFIED

Shabbat timer and elevator

CLAIM

Completing an electrical circuit is forbidden.

MECHANISM
THE LOOPHOLE — IN INTERNAL CONFLICT

The timer switches the light on by itself; the elevator stops at every floor without being called. The finger is the forbidden element, not the outcome. NOTE: this particular exit has been contested for decades — the halakhic literature records both strict and lenient positions, and in 2009 leading authorities in Israel ruled against Shabbat elevators.

SOURCES 1
Rabbi Chaim Jachter, "The Use of Elevators on Shabbat: Part I", Kol Torah, vol. 13 (2004) koltorah.org →
WORK · stands on

his room goes dark and his hands are tied.

and the switch is right there, at my side.

I'm the shabbos goy — I press without the sin,

the light was never against the law.

the hand was — that is all.

the lift stops at each floor as it goes.

nobody presses. nobody sins.

a finger is work — a timer is not,

so the ride to the sixth is long and slow.

the timer wakes the lamp at five.

a finger is sin. a spring is fine.

«BABY GOY» →